[Really in-depth looks at a bunch of the most famous murder ballads. Although, dammit, where’s The Twa Sisters? -egg]
So, why murder ballads? First and foremost, I think its because theyre essentially a form of journalism. Most of the songs youll find discussed here were written very soon after the real-life crimes they describe, and sold in the streets within hours of the killers capture or execution. Cheerfully vulgar, revelling in gore, and always with an eye on the main chance, these songs were tabloid newspapers set to music, carrying news of all the latest orrible murders to an insatiable public.
Then theres the fact that murder ballads never stop mutating, morphing to suit local place names as they cross and re-cross the Atlantic, and changing with the times as they move down the decades to fascinate each generations biggest musical stars. Victims are bludgeoned, stabbed or shot in every verse and killers are often hanged, but the songs themselves never die.
For all this mutability, the core facts of the story in each song are surprisingly persistent, and give us just enough information to follow a trail through the clippings library to the real individuals whose short lives and brutal deaths have become an indelible part of popular culture. No-ones going to care how you or I met our ends 100 years from now, but theyll still be singing Billy Lyons tale and recalling his fatal encounter with that bad man Stagger Lee.